security camera

Georgia Appeals Court Determines Whether Best Evidence Rule Was Applied

A Paulding County man’s conviction for armed robbery and aggravated assault was recently upheld by the Georgia Court of Appeals. The defendant argued that the Best Evidence Rule was violated because the state used photos from surveillance videos instead of the originals. However, the court found that prosecutors had introduced the original recordings, and the Marietta defense team’s appeal was denied. This decision reinforces how appellate courts in Georgia handle evidence and challenges based on trial errors.

Read More »
shadow of gun pointing at person

When Is a Robbery Attempt Not a Robbery Attempt?

The Georgia Court of Appeals reversed an armed robbery conviction from Cherokee County Superior Court, finding that the defendant’s actions did not meet the legal threshold for an attempted robbery under O.C.G.A. § 16-4-1.

The case involved a man who entered a pharmacy wearing a mask and carried suspicious notes suggesting intent, but no weapon was found and no robbery occurred. The Court ruled that these actions represented preparation rather than an actual attempt, a key distinction in Georgia criminal law.

This decision underscores the importance of understanding “substantial steps” vs. “mere preparation” in criminal attempt cases — and how a skilled Georgia criminal defense attorney can challenge evidence that doesn’t meet the burden of proof.

Read More »